Ajanah, Kogi Chief Judge in the eye of the storm
The Chief Judge of Kogi State, Justice Nasir Ajanah, has been having a running battle with the executive and the legislative arms of government in the state with the lawmakers recommending his removal. YINKA OLADOYINBO looks at the issues surrounding the ensuing judicial crisis in the state.
Justice Nasiru Ajanah the Chief Judge of Kogi State
By YINKA OLADOYINBO
Justice Nasir Ajanah, the Chief Judge of Kogi State, has been in the eye of the storm in the last couple of months as his position as the number one judge in the Confluence State is being threatened following a face-off between the executive arm of government and the judiciary on one hand and the legislative arm and the judiciary on another hand. Already, the state House of Assembly has recommended to the executive that he should be shown the way out because of an alleged gross misconduct.
The travails of Ajanah became a public knowledge when members of the state chapter of the Judiciary Staff Union of Nigeria (JUSUN) decided to boycott the table payment system adopted by the state government for payment of salaries of its workers. The government had become worried that, in spite of series of staff verification exercises it embarked upon, which lasted several months, the main objective of reducing its wage bill could not be achieved. The more the screening exercises continued, the more it became difficult for the total amount being spent on wages to reduce as expected.
Following the discovery, the state government had, last August, directed that every worker should be paid his or her salary through personal appearance, which again appeared to be another round of screening aimed at ascertaining the actual state work- force. The directive however generated controversies as the workers in the judiciary arm of government said they would not participate, arguing that they are working for a distinct arm of government that should not be taking directives from another arm.
They further said they had never been part of the screening exercises organised by the state government, wondering why the executive insisted that they should come forward for physical payment of salary. The chairman of the state chapter of JUSUN, Emmanuel Waniko, had stated that the state government’s decision to embark on table payment of part of the arrears of salaries owed the workers was not acceptable.
Waniko also argued that the government’s refusal to implement an upward review and timely remittance of the age-long monthly subvention due to the state judiciary could worsen the looming crisis between the union and the three levels of court in the state.
According to him, the combined management of the state’s High Court, Sharia Court of Appeal and Customary Court of Appeal was reportedly requested by the union to explain the modalities and time of payment of the five-month outstanding salaries owed staff of the judiciary. The union however frowned at the attempt by the executive to muscle the state’s third arm of government against the constitutional provisions that guarantees the financial independence of the judiciary.
For the Kogi JUSUN chairman, the development contravenes the recent legislative amendment to the constitution assented to by President Muhammadu Buhari and was aimed at strengthening the financial autonomy of state judiciaries and legislatures.
Prior to the introduction of the table payment arrangement, the executive was said to have stopped the monthly subvention of the judiciary which had led to the non-payment of the salary of workers in that arm of government. The workers consequently embarked on an industrial action to press home their demands as their salary was outstanding for about four months. The strike action had made the courts in the state to be locked for almost five months now.
The government was said to have made several entreaties to Justice Ajanah to prevail on the workers to come forward for the table payment but the Chief Judge was said to have sided with his people on their stand that the judiciary is not an appendage of the executive. The development made the executive, through the Secretary to the State Government (SSG), Mrs Folasade Ayoade, to write to the state legislature, asking the lawmakers to intervene in the looming crisis.
In the letter to the state House of Assembly, read by the Speaker, Matthew Kolawole, the SSG revealed that she had written a letter on 14 November, 2018, informing Ajanah of a request for the state judiciary’s payroll in preparation for table payment and pay parade exercise. But the Chief Judge replied, via a letter dated 16 November, 2018, declining the request on the ground, among others, that it impugned the independence and autonomy of the judiciary.
According to Mrs Ayoade, the stance of the state Chief Judge negated the earlier stand of the state House of Assembly of encouraging civil servants working in the legislature to participate in the exercise. She said the principle of Separation of Powers (SOP) stipulated that civil servants working in the state judiciary could not appear in their own workplace for the purpose of physical identification and collection of biometric data for the state integrated data base of its workers.
She said efforts she made to reach out to JUSUN to assure them of priority attention enjoyed by the state legislature and accord them same expeditious and respectful manner, were rebuffed.
The development made the state House of Assembly to set up a six-man committee, headed by the Majority Leader, Hassan Abdullahi, to interface with the judiciary and report back within a week.
However, sensing the trend of the events and the likely steps that can be taken by the executive and the legislature, the judiciary approached the state High Court, sitting in Koton Karfe, to seek for an injunction restraining the legislature from taking any step that may affect the Chief Judge and the Chief Registrar of the court, Yahaya Adamu, from performing their constitutional duties. The court, presided over by Justice Alaba Ajileye, granted the prayers of the applicants and this prevented the lawmakers from proceeding with activities brought about by the letter of the SSG.
As the Chief Judge was about to heave a sigh of relief and enjoy the peace that was occasioned by the injunction, the legislature came up with another joker that caught many of the followers of events in the state unawares. The lawmakers, at their sitting on April 3, 2019, received the report of the House Public Accounts Committee that looked into the financial dealings of some government organs and agencies.
Unfortunately for the Chief Judge, the judiciary was one of the organs that were investigated. At the end of the sitting, the state House of Assembly concluded that the judiciary was guilty. Chairman of the public accounts committee of the House, Alhaji Ahmed Mohammed, while presenting the report to the executive, said the Chief Judge should step aside to defend himself over his alleged indictment by the Auditor-General of the state.
According to Mohammed, the committee was set up at the plenary sitting of the House on December 24, 2018, in line with Section 103 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended). He said the state judiciary was said to have, in December 2016, spent its budget above the approved limits provided in some sub-heads as contained in the 2016 Appropriation Law to the tune of N7, 574, 850 without the approval of virement application.
He said: “It was also reported by the state Auditor-General that Kogi State High Court made huge cash withdrawal to the tune of N137, 607,334.11). The cash was withdrawn from High Court Bank account in the year under review. This transaction breached the provisions of chapter 6, regulation 632 which stipulates that “the use of cash for payment is hereby prohibited.”
The committee therefore, recommenced the removal of the Chief Judge for alleged gross misconduct or in the alternative he should step aside, pending his appearance before the House Committee on Public Accounts to defend himself.
Expectedly, the action of the lawmakers has been generating ripples in the state with many saying that the state government was only using the legislature to get at the Chief Judge as it appeared that the executive wanted Ajanah out of office at all cost.
Observers also argued that there was more to the executive/judiciary face-off than meet the eyes, particularly when the governor and the Chief Judge are of the Ebira extraction from the same Kogi Central Senatorial District of the state.
Speaking on the involvement of the legislature in the logjam, Speaker of the state House of Assembly, Kolawole said the legislative body can never be used by an arm of government to fight another arm of government. He said the report of the auditor-general had indicted the judiciary for spending more than the amount appropriated to it by the house.
He further explained that the public accounts committee of the house invited the Chief Judge on three occasions to defend the allegations but he refused to honour the invitations. He said such action, under the constitution, amounted to gross misconduct, saying it was one of the offences for which a chief judge could be removed from office. Kolawole noted that the legislature did not flout any court order by going ahead with the activities of the committee on public accounts, saying the issue was never before any court of competent jurisdiction.
According to the Kogi Assembly speaker, the issue that was taken before the Koton Karfe court by the embattled Chief Judge was the one that originated from the letter written to the SSG, seeking the intervention of the legislature in the impasse.
Again, not prepared to be caught napping, the Chief Judge and the Chief Registrar instituted another suit at the same Koton Karfe court, seeking the nullification of the resolution of the state House of Assembly. He argued that the resolution was arrived at in defiance to a subsisting order of the court. In a motion filed by their counsel, Adegboyega Awomolo SAN, the duo said the recommendation should be quashed as it was illegal, null and void.
Awomolo said the Motion on Notice HC/KK02M/201 was brought, pursuant to Order 11, Rules 1 and 2 of Kogi State High Court (Civil Procedure) Rules, 2006, to counter the action of the state legislature in defying the court order in the impasse between the legislative and the executive arms. The motion has Kogi State House of Assembly, Speaker of the House, Matthew Kolawole,
Honourable Bello Hassan Abdullahi, chairman of the ad-hoc committee; governor of Kogi State and the Attorney-General of the state as defendants.
According to the plaintiffs, the House of Assembly went ahead to sit and issue a resolution on the matter, despite the pendency of Suit NO. HC/KK/11CV/2018 and an interim injunctive order of the court. They prayed for an order of the court nullifying and setting aside the resolution passed by the House at its plenary sitting of 2 April, 2019, in defiance of the pendency of the suit.
The claimants also brought the motion on the grounds that the purported resolution of the first-third defendants was made during the pendency of the suit and a subsisting order of the court restraining the defendants from taking any steps in respect of the substantive matter. However, on 12 April when the motion was to be moved, the court had to postpone its sitting on the matter indefinitely, based on the pervading security situation around the court premises.
The attempt to remove the Chief Judge of Kogi State is another avenue to test the provisions of the 1999 Constitution (as amended) on the removal of judicial officers. Section 292 (1) of the constitution provides that “A judicial officer shall not be removed from his office or appointment before his age of retirement except in the following circumstances: (a) in the case of –
(i) Chief Justice of Nigeria, President of the Court of Appeal, Chief Judge of the Federal High Court, Chief Judge of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja, Grand Kadi of the Sharia Court of Appeal of the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja and President, Customary Court of Appeal of the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja, by the president acting on an address supported by two-thirds majority of the Senate;
(ii) Chief Judge of a state, Grand Kadi of a Sharia Court of Appeal or President of a Customary Court of Appeal of a state, by the governor acting on an address supported by two-thirds majority of the House of Assembly of the state-praying that he be so removed for his inability to discharge the functions of his office or appointment (whether arising from infirmity of mind or of body) or for misconduct or contravention of the Code of Conduct;
(b) in any case, other than those to which paragraph (a) of this subsection applies, by the president or, as the case may be, the governor acting on the recommendation of the National Judicial Council (NJC) that the judicial officer be so removed for his inability to discharge the functions of his office or appointment (whether arising from infirmity of mind or of body) or for misconduct or contravention of the Code of Conduct.”
It is expected that the processes on the removal of Ajanah as the Chief Judge of Kogi State would have to be brought before the NJC, a body that is constitutionally empowered to recommend the removal of any judicial officer to either the president or the governor as the case may be.
Culled from Nigerian Tribune
Kogi mourns death of first class chief, Okwutachi
Kogi mourns death of
first class chief, Okwutachi
Kogi State Governor, Yahaya Bello has expressed shock over the passage of a First Class paramount ruler of Abocho in Dekina Local Government Area of the state, Alhaji Tijani Okutachi.
The Royal Father passed on to the great beyond on the 28 November,2020 at the age of 61 following an illness.
Governor Bello in a condelence message issued on Sunday by his Chief Press Secretary, Onogwu Muhammed described the the Royal Father as a great promoter of peace and unity amongst his subjects.
According to him, the passage of the paramount ruler happening months after that of the Attah Igala, Dr Michael Idakwo Ameh Oboni II, was one tragedy too many for the Igala kingdom in particular and Kogi State as a whole.
He said the 20-year reign of the paramount ruler on the throne, has no doubt attracted significant developments and progress to his people.
Bello said the paramount ruler would be greatly missed for his royal counsels, fatherly guidance and various contributions for the overall good of the state.
He prayed God to grant his soul Aljannah firdaus and fortitude for his family to bear the loss.
Senator Abbo eulogises Nuhu Ribadu as a worthy mentor at 60
Senator Abbo eulogises Nuhu Ribadu as a worthy mentor at 60
By Joseph Sunday
The senator representing Adamawa North senatorial district Elisha Abbo has taken to his facebook page to Eulogise Nuhu Ribadu describing him as a worthy boss as he celebrates his 60th birthday.
The senate who described the former EFCC boss as a detribalized NIgerian said Nigeria is Lucky to have him.
He recalled his own personal political trajectory which he said had a lot in connection with the former presidential candidate of defunct Action Congress of Nigeria (ACN) whom he served as personal assistant, special assistant and more of personal Confidant.
“In 2010, I resigned my appointment as Special Adviser to the Governor of Adamawa state to join your team as a volunteer.
“Eventually I became your personal assistant (PA) then Special Assistant (SA) and much more – personal confidant (PC).
“Infact a day before you came back from exile, I met Mr. Falana Falana SAN in his Ikeja Office, three of us received you in the Airport in Lagos that’s your elder brother (Dan Galadima), your younger brother Ismaila and myself.
“Since your Hotel room key was with me, I took you to your room in Protea Hotel Ikeja, Lagos. “The next day we went to Babcock University where you were Honored with a Doctorate Degree ( Honoris Causa)”
Abbo said he was so close to him that he holds his phones, drive with him in the same cars, organize his diary, fly in the same plane with him sometimes private jets borrowed from his friends like Alhaji Dangote, Senator Andy Uba, Asiwaju Ahmed Bola Tinubu among others.
He said against the wish of Ribadu he Police Details and Security on him in 2011 when he met the then Commissioner of Police of FCT ( Mr Sinaba) and requested for police protection.
“I remembered how you tongue lashed me for three days for bringing police to your house without your authorization.”
The senate said he lived an honest simple life adding that he always committed his life in the hands of God Almighty. “You are one of the most connected and respected Nigerians alive. What a man!!!”
“Few days ago we met on a flight to Yola and also met the next day in the Church in Mubi during the wedding ceremony of the daughter of Ambassador @Kevinpeter where you delivered a powerful speech about love Unity and Trust.”
He said the thought provoking admonition held the church spell bound when his words changed a lot that day.
Activist calls for removal of Kogi HOS, NLC says continued stay illegal
Activist calls for removal of Kogi HOS, NLC says continued stay illegal
By Friday Idachaba
Human Rights activist, Mr Idris Miliki, has called on Kogi Government to immediately remove Mrs Deborah Ogunmola as the state Head of Service (HOS) for perpetuating herself in office for two years after retirement.
Miliki who is also the Executive Director of Kogi-based Conscience for Human Rights and Conflict Resolution (CHRCR) made the call in a statement made available to the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) on Friday in Lokoja.
The activist described the continued stay in office of the Head of Service as “fraudulent, illegal, unconstitutional, immoral, an abuse of office and unjustifiable.”
He called on Kogi state government which he described as “a product judicial process”, to immediately remove the HOS as every action carried out by her since the expiration of her tenure amounted to illegality.
Miliki also called on the the Organised Labour to ignore forthwith, in all ramifications, her directives and actions as the occupant of that office as doing otherwise would amount to perpetuating illegality.
In similar vein, Mr Onuh Edoka, chairman of the Nigeria Labour Congress (NLC) said Mrs Ogunmola had exceeded the statutory 35 years of service.
Edoka pointed out that it was ironical for Ogunmola to set aside the same circular she signed prohibiting contract appointments saying, “No retired civil servant would be given contract appointment.”
According to him, the HOS signed the circular herself and had now turned around to perpetuate herself in office claiming to be on contract appointment, an abnormality she sought to correct in the state civil service.
The labour leader therefore, appealed to Governor Yahaya Bello to appoint a new Head of Service to supervise the activities of the state civil service.
He explained that keeping Ogunmola in office, “when she would have retired two years ago” amounted to disservice to qualified and hardworking staff whose elevation her continued stay in office had hindered.
Edoka said Kogi state civil servants could no longer be ruled by a retired HOS saying, “There are many Permanent Secretaries and other qualified civil servants who can do the job even better.
“What we are saying is for the government to see reason with workers and do the needful by allowing her to commence her retirement”, Edoka added. (NAN)
News2 years ago
PDP asks Kogi Finance Commissioner to bury his Head In Shame as no Single Project Executed
Media3 years ago
Igala nation rejects alleged inclusion in Map of Biafra
Metro3 years ago
SARS kills Notorious Criminal in a gun duel in Kogi, as gang members burns down police post
News3 years ago
Kogi State University commences recruitment of fresh lecturers to replace striking ones
Metro3 years ago
Police parades Naval rating, two serving Police officers over attempted kidnap of 5year old
Legislature3 years ago
NGO Honours Egwu for outstanding performance in two years
Features4 years ago
The many (mis)adventures of Gov. Yahaya Bello
News4 years ago
Authors in Kogi bankroll maiden edition of literary contest for schools and colleges