Connect with us

law

Onnoghen:CCT dismisses no case submission

Published

on

Spread the love

Onnoghen:CCT dismisses no case submission

The Code of Conduct Tribunal (CCT), yesterday, dismissed the no case submission filed last week by the suspended Chief Justice of Nigeria, Justice Walter Onnoghen.

Justice Onnoghen through his counsel, Adegboyega Awomolo (SAN), had filed a no case submission when the prosecution closed its case after calling only three witnesses.

The matter was then adjourned till yesterday. And at the resumed sitting, Onnoghen’s lawyer, Adegboyega Awomolo (SAN), urged the tribunal to quash the charges against his client on the ground that the Code of Conduct Bureau did not comply with relevant laws before filing the charge.

He submitted that CCB also failed to investigate the petition brought against Onnoghen by Denis Aganya before proceeding to file a charge before the CCT.

According to the defense counsel, the two asset declaration forms submitted by Justice Onnoghen were not verified by CCB before charges were filed.

He also argued that the evidence given by the three prosecution witnesses were discredited in the course of cross-examination.

Read More: FG closes suit, Onnoghen to file ‘no case’ submission

In addition, he noted that the witnesses were not signatories or makers of the documents tendered at the tribunal.

However, delivering ruling on the no case submission,” the chairman of the tribunal, Danladi Umar, held that there were sufficient grounds to compel Justice Onnoghen to enter his defence, especially in view of the confessional statement he made on his undeclared bank accounts.

Danladi was of the view that by filing the no case submission, Justice Onnoghen attempted at evading punishment due to him in relation to his confessional statement.

Umar further stated that the defendant’s argument that the procedure was not followed did not reduce that an offense has been committed by his failure to declare his account with the Standard Chartered Bank.

He added that his duty as the chairman of the tribunal was to do justice to the charge brought before the tribunal irrespective of the manner in which it came.

“This is the court that relies on the substance of the charge and not on the procedure,” Umar stated. The CCT boss added that, “this tribunal will never fail to administer justice to whosoever appears before it irrespective of status. After all, everyone is equal before God.

“From the President to the shoemaker, we are all equal. The ‘No case submission’ is hereby discountenanced and refused”, he said.

With this, Umar adjourned the matter till next week Monday.

Trouble, however, started when the defence counsel pleaded for extension of time to enable the defendant prepare for his defence.

Awomolo had prayed Umar to adjourn till next Friday but he insisted that the matter continues on Monday.

In an emotion laden voice, Awomolo pleaded with the CCT boss to reconsider his stand in the interest of justice.

“Give us, give us, give us, don’t oppress us, you are oppressing us,” he said. But as he continued with his pleading, Umar, without looking back, took a bow and stormed out of the courtroom.

As soon as Umar left the courtroom, the defense teams for both parties engaged in a shouting match that lasted several minutes.

Awomolo insisted that the defense team in support of the no case submission raised eight points.

According to him, there was no proper investigation before charges were filed and there was no compliance with the law in the entire process. “We cannot fight corruption with corrupt practice, lies and propaganda. The chairman has taken over the power of the two other members of the tribunal, not allowing them to talk.

“There was nothing before the tribunal but the chairman was using his own experience to give ruling. If this is judgment in the face of Nigeria, then the country is doomed”, Awomolo stated.

Meanwhile, Justice Onnoghen has quickly filed a notice of appeal challenging the decision of CCT.

The appeal was predicated upon three grounds, including the fact that the tribunal erred in law when it dismissed his no case submission without taking due process into cognisance.

Onnoghen claimed that the CCB was bound by the Code of Conduct standard operation procedure 2017 with respect to investigation and report of investigation.

He also relied on the testimony of the first witness where he stated that investigation has not been conducted.

He, therefore, prayed the Court of Appeal to set aside the decision of the tribunal, which stated that he has a case to answer.

Above all, he wants the court to discharge and acquit him.

Culled from The Guardian

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

law

Autonomy for Judiciary has no alternative – Out-going Kogi CJ

Published

on

By

Spread the love

Autonomy for Judiciary has no alternative – Out-going Kogi CJ

By Friday Idachaba

Out-going Chief Judge of Kogi, Justice Henry Olusiyi has said that there is no alternative to the total independence and autonomy of the Judiciary if the third arm of government must discharge its functions creditably.

Olusiyi disclosed this in his speech at the valedictory court session held in his honour on his retirement as the Chief Judge of the state at the High Court complex on Monday in Lokoja.

The Chief Judge held that the Judiciary had the duty of ensuring that every citizen of the country lived a life of dignity and not deprived of “right to life” guaranteed to him under the Constitution.

“In a country which professes to follow the Rule of Law and the principle of Separation of Powers, there is no alternative to a totally Independent judiciary.

“All the three arms of government: The Legislature, Executive and Judiciary are expected to and must work together for achieving the goals set out in the constitution. There must be harmony between the three arms.

“The doctrine of Separation of Powers as enshrined in our Constitution is to ensure checks and balances among the three arms of government to avoid the abuse of power and the risk of one arm wielding absolute power to the detriment of the other arms.

“The rule of law is the fabric that holds society together. Any breach of the rule of law is a potential danger for the sustenance of law and order in the society. Court orders should be respected and complied with as a matter of course”, he said.

The state Attorney General and Commissioner for Justice, Ibrahim Mohammed (SAN) said the tenure of the Chief Judge, though short, was eventful as he was leaving with his footsteps in the sand.

Mohammed said that during the brief period of six months the Executive Arm of government in the state enjoyed a cordial relationship with the Judiciary under Justice Olusiyi.

Usman O. Sule (SAN), representing the body of Senior Advocates of Nigeria (SAN), said, posterity would be kind to Olusiyi as a forthright, fearless and independent minded Judge who delivered his judgements without fear or favour, affection or ill-will.

Sule said the jurist had always ensured and showed that parties who appear before him go home happy with sound result of fair hearing, fair trial and sound judgement.

Mr Sam Owoyomi, chairman, Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) Lokoja branch, who spoke on behalf of other branches in the state described Olusiyi as a child of destiny who had fulfilled destiny.

He said that the Out-going Chief Judge was honest, bold, courageous, incorruptible, impartial judge of great characters and erudition.

Owoyomi urged the authorities to ensure full autonomy was granted the Judiciary.

Pioneer Chief Judge of the state, Justice Umaru Eri (rtd), the Grand Khadi of the state Sharia Court of Appeal, Justice Abdulkareem Aruwa and Justice Sunday Otu, delivered goodwill messages at the occasion.

The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that Justice Olusiyi retired whose judicial career started in 1980 retired today, January 11 on attainment of the mandatory 65 years of age. (NAN)

FDJ/

Continue Reading

law

Another big win for Obaseki as court quashes certificate forgery case against him

Published

on

By

Spread the love

 
Another big win for Obaseki as court quashes certificate forgery case against him

Governor Godwin Obaseki has again triumphed over his traducers as they failed to prove the certificate forgery case against him
This is as Federal High Court in Abuja, on Saturday, threw out the certificate forgery case the All Progressives Congress, APC, and one of  its members, Mr. Williams Edobor, instituted against him.
The trial judge, Justice Ahmed Mohammed, held that the Plaintiffs, failed to by way of credible evidence, discharge the burden of proof placed on them by the law.
Justice Mohammed insisted there was no iota of evidence before the court to establish that Obaseki forged either his O’level certificate or the degree certificate that was awarded to him in 1979 by the University of Ibadan.
He held that allegation of forgery the Plaintiffs levelled against Obaseki bordered on crime and therefore required to be proved beyond reasonable doubt.

“None of the witnesses called by the Plaintiffs was able to prove that the certificate was forged as alleged.

“In fact, the witnesses admitted that none of them visited the University of Ibadan to confirm the authenticity of the certificate.

“The Plaintiffs only relied on photocopies that were attached to the Form EC9 the 1st Defendant submitted to the Independent National Electoral Commission”, the court noted.
It held that apparent discrepancies in the documents Obaseki submitted to INEC, “were satisfactorily explained”
Obaseki against all permutations had won the 2020 Edo Governorship election even after he was forced to dump his party APC for the PDP few weeks to the election.

He defeated his main rival Pastor Osagie Ize-Iyamu in the election with a wide margin.

Continue Reading

law

Kogi CJ charges new judicial officers to be guided by Justice

Published

on

By

Spread the love

Kogi CJ charges new judicial officers to be guided by Justice

By Friday Idachaba

Chief Judge of Kogi, Justice Henry Olusiyi has inaugurated 10 newly appointed Magistrates and Area Judges with a call on judicial officers to be guided by the Oath of Office they take and Justice.

Olusiyi who made the call at the inaugural ceremony of eight Magistrates and two Area Court Judges in Lokoja on Friday said the event of oath-taking was a solemn one that should not be taken lightly.

“The Oath you have just taken is not a thing to be taken lightly. So, I charge you to be guided by the oath you took. You took the oath on the basis of the Holy Qur’an and the Holy Bible as the case may be. So, these two instruments should be your guide.

“An Oath is binding, an Oath is irrevocable, an Oath is irreversible and that is why you did not do it inadvertently, you do it with seriousness.

“Oath taking is not an empty practice, its not a casual thing, its a thing that should be taken seriously if we take our oaths seriously then we will take our jobs seriously and we will be committed”, he said.

Olusiyi wondered how many public officers sit down, even for one day, to take a look at the oaths they took, to see if they were living or working in line with their oaths.

He therefore urged that the oath should be a constant reminder of their duties saying, “My dear Magistrates and Area Court Judges, be guided by the fear of God which is the beginning of wisdom and you need wisdom to discharge the functions of this office.

He commended them to the words of their oaths and the Holy Books for constant guidance saying that the work of adjudication was a divine one with which God had entrusted them.

“God is the ultimate judge and we have been given the rare privilege to judge our fellow human beings. So, by that, it has put us in the class of God. Let us be constantly mindful of this fact.

“You are an ambassador of God. Do not allow yourself to be compromised by any interest. The only interest that should guide you is the interest of Justice”, added.

Olusiyi reminded the newly appointed judicial officers that Justice was about discovering the truth and that they should be guided by the truth adding that Justice was not a luxury as access to Justice remained the inalienable right of every citizen

“Access to Justice is a means of enforcing the Fundamental Rights of citizens and this can only be done through the courts. Courts that are manned by legally trained officers”, he said.

Olusiyi who was full of gratitude to God, the state Judicial Service Commission (JSC) and his brother judges said the judicial officers were carefully selected to fill some vacancies and gaps.

Speaking on behalf of the newly appointed judicial officers, Mr Joseph Ajesola (Chief Magistrate I) thanked the Chief Judge for finding them worthy of the appointments.

He pledged not to do anything that could tarnish the image of the Judiciary with a promises to make constant reference to the oaths taken.

The new judicial officers include Eleojo Audi, Chief Magistrate I; Rekiya Amehadaji, Senior Magistrate I; Owonibi Olayemi, Magistrate II; Avazi Ohunene, Senior Magistrate II; Salihu Rafatu, Magistrate I; Ademu Fatima, Magistrate II and Ipinera Sunday as Senior Magistrate I.

Albert Agada, appointed as Magistrate II and who would have made the ninth magistrate was however absent at the inauguration while the two Area Court judges are Olusegun Abosede, Senior Area Court Judge I and Olowosegun Lucy, Senior Area Court Judge II.

The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that the Chief Judge used the occasion to announce the confirmation of the Acting Chief Registrar of the state High Court, Mr Augustine Ayinmiro as the substantive Chief Registrar of the state High Court. (NAN)

FDJ/

Continue Reading

Trending